The Second Fob Files: What Private-Hire Drivers Need to Prove Before Handback
Photo: Collins, Tudor Washington, 1898-1970, photographer, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Hiring a private-hire vehicle usually means a brisk handover: paperwork, a walkaround, a quick jab at the buttons, then off you go. The second key fob often gets the least attention of anything in the deal. It is also one of the easiest things to lose, damage or misunderstand — and one of the simplest ways for a deposit to shrink at handback.
This isn't about being paranoid. It's about knowing what you've signed for. A spare fob on a hired private-hire car is not just a lump of plastic with a badge on it. It is a programmed security device, part of the vehicle's inventory, and sometimes the difference between the car going back on the road and sitting in a yard waiting for a costly recode.
Two keys handed over, two keys expected back
Most hire agreements list the keys somewhere. It might be a tick box, a line in the vehicle condition report, or a note in the schedule. Make sure it says two. If you collect the car with one fob and a promise that the other is 'in the office', get that promise in writing before you leave. A text or email from the hire company is fine. A verbal assurance is not much use three weeks later when someone different is checking the car back in.
Ask a blunt question: are both fobs present, working and part of the hire? Then ask whether both must come back. The answer should be yes. If the second fob is being held by the operator for security reasons, get that confirmed too, along with who holds it and what happens if it goes missing while the car is with you.
The fob is not the cheap bit — the coding is
Drivers often assume a replacement key is a £20 job. On a modern car, it can be far more. The fob itself, the key blade, the programming, the immobiliser coding and sometimes a lock change can add up quickly. Keyless systems can be especially expensive to sort out. A missing fob may also affect the vehicle's insurance and security status until the operator has dealt with it.
That is why hire firms treat second keys seriously. If one is missing at handback, they may not simply charge for a blank fob. They may charge for making the car secure again. Whether they can do that from your deposit depends on the agreement, but you should not assume the deposit is only there for dents and kerbed alloys.
Photograph the fobs like they're part of the bodywork
Before you drive off, do a proper key check. Press the lock, unlock and boot buttons. Check the casing for cracks, missing buttons or tape holding it together. Look at the key blade if it is the type that folds out. Note any existing damage, because a fob that was already cracked when you collected it should not become your problem later.
Then photograph both fobs together, front and back, next to the hire agreement or a dated note. Take a short video of each one working. It sounds fussy, but it takes less than a minute and gives you a clean record if there is a dispute. If the car has a key tag or fleet number, include that in the photo. Do not photograph any security code if one is visible; you only need condition and presence, not the secret numbers.
Also check the battery. A fob that is already struggling on collection is worth flagging. It is not usually a chargeable item, but a flat battery can look like a fault later. Ask the operator to note it or replace the battery before you leave.
Key cover is not a magic wand
Some hire desks offer key cover or excess protection at the counter. Read what it actually covers. Many policies have exclusions for commercial use, private hire, business use or keys lost through negligence. Some require a police report for theft. Some cap the payout well below the real replacement cost. Others may cover the fob but not the coding or lock change.
If you are hiring for private-hire work, say so clearly and ask whether the cover applies to that use. Get the answer in writing if you can. Do not buy key cover on the assumption that it solves every key problem. It may be useful, but it is not a substitute for knowing where both fobs are.
Keep the spare fob away from the glovebox
The spare key is a security risk if it lives in the car. A thief who finds it can drive away without forcing anything. Keep it somewhere secure and separate from the vehicle documents. If you lose a fob, tell the hire company straight away. Do not wait until handback. Early reporting gives them a chance to advise you and may reduce the risk of the car being targeted. If a fob is stolen, report it to the police and get a crime reference number — your hire firm and any insurer will likely want it.
Handback is a checklist, not a shrug
On return day, hand back both fobs and get the check-in sheet signed. If the operator keeps the keys, ask for a receipt or a note confirming both were returned. If there is a dispute about condition or missing items, stay calm and ask for the charge to be itemised in writing. A deposit deduction should be explainable, not plucked from the air.
At Crystal Cars, the rule is simple: if it came with the car, it goes back with the car, and if it costs money to replace, you should know the figure before you sign. The second fob is small, easy to overlook and quietly valuable. Treat it like part of the vehicle, not an afterthought, and you will have a much quieter handback.