Subscriptions, Leases and PCP: Which One Survives Contact With a Private-Hire Driver's Mileage?
Photo: car finance contract signing dealership UK customer, via amazingcarsanddrives.com
Walk into any dealership in 2026 and you will be offered at least three ways to get the same car off the forecourt. A subscription, a personal lease, or a PCP. All three are presented as 'from £299 a month' and all three mean something completely different once you read past the headline.
For a private-hire driver, the difference is not academic. It is the gap between a workable weekly outgoing and a £3,000 penalty letter eighteen months in.
First, the plain-English version
A subscription is a rolling rental. One monthly payment covering the car, servicing, tyres, roadside assistance and often insurance. Minimum terms are short, sometimes one month, sometimes six. Nothing to own at the end, no deposit in most cases.
A personal lease (PCH) is a fixed-term rental, usually two to four years, with an upfront payment of three to nine months and a mileage allowance written into the contract. Servicing can be bundled for a few pounds a month. At the end you hand the keys back and walk away, provided the car passes the wear-and-tear check.
A PCP is a hire purchase deal with a balloon payment at the end. You pay a deposit, then monthly instalments, and at the end of the term you either pay the final payment (the Guaranteed Minimum Future Value), hand the car back, or part-exchange it. You can also voluntarily terminate once you have paid half the total amount payable, which is a real right under the Consumer Credit Act, not a favour.
Running the numbers on a £28,000 car
These are illustrative 2026 figures, so treat them as a shape rather than a quote. Always get your own.
- PCP: £3,500 deposit, 48 months at £329, final payment around £9,800, 10,000 miles a year, excess mileage at 12p. Cash out over the term: roughly £19,300. You own nothing at the end unless you find the balloon.
- Lease: nine months upfront at £322, then 35 payments of £322, three years, 10,000 miles a year, excess at 9p plus VAT. Total: about £14,200 over 36 months. You hand it back.
- Subscription: £649 a month all-in, one-month rolling after a six-month minimum, 1,000 miles a month included. Twelve months: about £7,800. No deposit, no balloon, no equity.
On the surface the subscription looks expensive per month and the lease looks cheapest over three years. Both readings are correct and both are useless until you add the one variable that matters.
The mileage allowance is where this gets decided
A typical private-hire driver covering 30,000 miles a year is doing 2,500 a month. Now run the three contracts against that number.
- Subscription: the cap is 1,000 miles a month. That is 1,500 extra miles every month, charged at something like 25p to 35p a mile. Call it £450 a month on top. Your all-in £649 becomes £1,100.
- PCP: the contract says 10,000 a year. You are doing 30,000. That is 20,000 excess miles a year at 12p, so £2,400 a year, or £7,200 over three years. On top of the payments already made.
- Lease: high-mileage leases do exist, at 20,000 to 30,000 a year, and they cost more. A 25,000-mile contract might sit at £450 a month with nine months down. Total over three years: roughly £16,200 for 75,000 miles.
Suddenly the cheap-looking option is the one with the smallest mileage cap. This is not a trick. It is simply how the products are priced. Low-mileage assumptions are baked into the monthly figure.
The per-mile calculation that settles arguments
Add up everything you will actually pay, deposit included, and divide by the total miles the contract allows.
- Lease at 25,000 miles: £16,200 ÷ 75,000 = about 22p per mile, before insurance and servicing.
- PCP at 10,000 miles: £19,300 ÷ 40,000 = about 48p per mile, and that is before the excess mileage charge lands.
- Subscription at 1,000 a month: £7,800 ÷ 12,000 = 65p per mile, unless you blow the cap.
That single figure tells you more than any monthly quote. Compare it to what a three-year-old used car would cost you in depreciation, repairs and downtime.
Exit fees, wear and tear, and the small print
Subscriptions usually let you hand the car back with a month or two of notice after the minimum term, but check the early termination charge, because it is often a fixed fee rather than a rolling one.
Leases are the hardest to escape. Early termination is expensive, and end-of-contract recharges for kerbed alloys, door dings and worn tyres are where the profit sits. Photograph everything at handover and get the inspection report in writing.
PCP has the clearest exit right of the three, the half-way voluntary termination, plus the option to settle early or sell privately if the car is worth more than the settlement figure. But if you signed up to 10,000 miles and drove 90,000, the excess charge follows the car, not the finance company's conscience.
The bit nobody mentions at the desk
Private-hire insurance. A subscription that includes insurance almost certainly includes a standard policy that excludes hire and reward. Read that line twice. If it excludes your actual job, you need a private-hire policy, and the provider may not allow it on their vehicle at all.
Leases and PCPs leave insurance to you, which is cleaner, but a hire-and-reward policy is a serious annual cost in most UK cities. It belongs in the per-mile maths, not in a separate mental box.
So who should pick what
- Subscription: short-term gaps, a licence issue, a car written off, or a driver testing whether an EV suits the school run and the airport queue. Not for 30,000 miles a year unless a high-mileage subscription is priced honestly.
- Lease: the driver who wants a fixed cost, keeps the car clean, and can commit to a realistic mileage figure. High-mileage leases are the underrated option for full-time private hire.
- PCP: lower-mileage drivers, or anyone who wants to own the car outright and is comfortable with a balloon payment at the end. For high mileage, the excess charge is the whole story.
None of the three is a rip-off. They are just built for different drivers, and the sales patter rarely mentions which one you are.